On this page
concept

Markdown Optimisation

Created 2026-06-26 Updated 2026-11-04 58 connections

Markdown Optimisation

Markdown optimisation is the discipline of deciding the timing and depth of permanent price reductions used to clear seasonal or slow-moving inventory while protecting as much margin as possible. Sources frame it as the end-of-lifecycle counterpart to Promotional Uplift Modelling: Toolio draws the line that "a price adjustment to manage in-season velocity is fundamentally different from a markdown to clear end-of-season excess — the first protects margin, the second recovers what's left of it" (Toolio, vendor, updated 2026-05-29). In fashion/apparel it is a structurally large lever because a high share of units now move at a discount, and each reduction erodes planned margin disproportionately. It sits inside the merchandise-planning stack alongside Merchandise Financial Planning (MFP) (which budgets the markdown reserve) and Open-to-Buy (OTB) (whose formula includes planned markdowns).

Sourcing note (2026-08-08 update): The 2026-06-26 run was web-only. This run adds registry (EU primary source, McKinsey PDF, IDC primary) and YouTube search (Apify unavailable — videos identified, no transcripts). Reddit remains unavailable in the Cowork cloud environment. The EU ESPR section has been upgraded from unverified to fully primary-sourced. McKinsey figures have been attributed to their correct 2019 and 2018 source documents with stale-risk flags added. The "unverified" callout on the 400–800 bps figure has been replaced by a contradiction callout. RELEX IDC MarketScape details updated with the correct 2025–2026 edition identifier.

Sourcing note (2026-11-04 update): Web-only run (reddit-research MCP and Apify YouTube transcripts remain unavailable in this environment). Added: named practitioner corroboration of 50% sell-through (TheIndustry.fashion 2026-05-14); one deep-cut vs. incremental-ladder section (Competera 2026-08-28); consumer discount-conditioning risk (RetailNext 2026 primary survey); wholesale/B2B markdown dynamics — "markdown money" mechanism (SPS Commerce 2026-08-13); tariff-driven overstock risk (IHL Group 2026 primary); vendor AI case studies (Increff, Metyis, Markmi, Pricen, all low-confidence). Gaps from prior runs remain unfilled: no empirical head-to-head on cut strategies; no independent small-retailer ROI; YouTube/Reddit still blocked.

Why it matters: the margin math

Eightx illustrates the asymmetry that makes markdowns expensive: a 15% markdown does not cost 15% of margin. On a $100 unit at 55% gross margin ($45 cost), a 15% cut drops gross profit from $55 to $40 — "more than a quarter of your gross profit dollars gone"; a 30% cut drops it to $25; and a ~55% clearance sells at cost for zero profit (Eightx 2026-06-08, labelled an illustrative model, not a measured stat). Toolio makes the same point on the velocity side: "a 70% [sell-through rate] with zero markdowns is worth more than a 90% STR after a 30% promotional discount" (Toolio, vendor, updated 2026-05-29).

Competera extends the asymmetry calculation (2026-08-28): on the same $100 item (cost $45), a 40% markdown reduces gross profit by approximately 73% — from $55 to $15 — far larger than the 40% discount implies. This arithmetic is verifiable from the stated figures and explains why vendors universally frame markdown timing as a margin-critical decision.

The structural backdrop (all vendor-attributed unless otherwise noted, treat as directional):

  • Markdowns consume an estimated 20–50% of net sales at many fashion retailers (Markmi and Eightx, both citing McKinsey) (as-of 2026-06-26).

The "20–50% of net sales" figure is widely attributed to McKinsey across secondary sources. The most likely primary source is a McKinsey PDF titled "Pairing advanced analytics with intuitive tools to transform retail markdown management," published July 2019 (mckinsey.com). This is a six-year-old document; no accessible McKinsey publication with this specific figure from 2024–2026 was found in the 2026-08-08 registry search. Treat the figure as directionally plausible but structurally stale.

  • Full-price sell-through has reportedly fallen from an old 70–75% norm to ~50% at many retailers — i.e. about half of all units now move at a discount. This claim, originally from Markmi and Eightx (vendor sources, 2026-06-26), is now independently corroborated by Philip Mountford, former CEO of Hunkemöller: "There are more fashion retailers with 50% full-price sell-through than there were pre-COVID" (TheIndustry.fashion 2026-05-14). C&A's Markus Krenn describes markdowns as "one of the biggest cost lines in our P&L," with his team now debating which seasonal markdown strategy to use rather than which individual product to discount (TheIndustry.fashion 2026-05-14) (as-of 2026-05-14).

  • BCG survey of 350 retailers (described as "this year" in a 2026-05-14 article, survey labelled 2025): merchants spend 40% of their time on manual tasks that could be automated — a data point often cited to justify optimisation software (secondary cite via TheIndustry.fashion; original BCG report not fetched) (as-of 2025, stale-risk).

A worked example of the downstream P&L sensitivity is independently grounded: per its 10-K filed 2026-03-30, American Eagle's gross margin slipped to 36.5% in FY2025 from 39.2% the prior year, and operating income fell 47%, from $427.3M to $226.2M — a 2.7-point gross-margin slip nearly halving operating income (Eightx 2026-06-08, citing the SEC filing) (as-of 2026-03-30).

Markdown vs promotion (the definitional line)

Centric Software enumerates markdown types — clearance (at or below cost for slow sellers), seasonal, loss leaders, end-of-life, dynamic (real-time supply/demand timing), competitive, and promotional — and explicitly frames promotional cuts as "temporary price cuts, circular promotions, coupons, and other limited time price reductions," separate from inventory-clearing markdowns (Centric Software, vendor, 2024-06-25). This is the boundary that separates this page from Promotional Uplift Modelling: markdowns are permanent and inventory-driven; promotions are temporary and demand-driven.

Markdown cadence and depth (fashion)

Sources converge on a shallow, few-step, trigger-based approach rather than deep calendar-driven cuts:

  • Eightx: best practice is a shallow first markdown of 10–25%, with only 2–3 steps across a season, differentiated by how price-sensitive the style is, on the principle "you can always discount deeper, you can never put the price back up" (attributed to Centric Software guidance plus BCG fashion-markdown research, Eightx 2026-06-08).
  • Toolio's structured cadence: Phase 1 (weeks 1–3 post-peak) 10–15% on slow movers; Phase 2 (weeks 4–6) 20–30% if Phase 1 didn't hit velocity; Phase 3 (end-of-season) deeper clearance with a floor at landed cost plus minimum acceptable margin (Toolio, vendor, updated 2026-05-29).
  • Eightx: the first markdown should be triggered by a sell-through threshold, not a calendar date — at the midpoint of a style's selling window, styles materially below their sell-through curve get a small automatic cut (Eightx 2026-06-08).
  • Centric: markdown ladders (the discount percentages shoppers see) typically begin at 10% and deepen; cuts under ~5% "do not move consumers"; and blanket category-wide markdowns waste margin on healthy SKUs versus precise SKU/colour/size-level selection (Centric Software, vendor, 2024-06-25).
  • Luc De Baets (Buying Director, Torfs): marks down select items early to drive traffic, then applies the right discount at the right time, rather than discounting everything from day one (TheIndustry.fashion 2026-05-14, paraphrase) (as-of 2026-05-14).

Sell-through benchmarks driving the trigger

Toolio reports healthy apparel/fashion Sell-Through Rate at 65–85% (fast fashion 85%+, basics 65–70%), with end-of-season STR below 60% triggering markdown escalation for most buying teams (as-of 2026-06-26). By vertical it cites Health & Beauty 75–90%, Sporting Goods 70–85%, General Retail 70–80%, Consumer Electronics 60–75%, Home & Furniture 55–75%, Luxury & Jewellery 50–65% (low STR partly intentional for scarcity) (Toolio, vendor, updated 2026-05-29).

One deep cut vs. incremental markdown ladder

A live debate in vendor literature, with no empirical head-to-head to adjudicate it:

  • Staged/incremental approach (margin-protection argument): Competera (2026-08-28) argues that incremental markdowns "usually protect more margin because the retailer can stop as soon as the product starts selling again." The gross-profit asymmetry above supports the logic — stopping a staged markdown early costs far less than reversing a deep cut already taken. Increff (updated 2026-10-06) similarly advises judging scenarios on "margin and sell-through together, not on clearance speed alone," noting that a SKU with strong Price Elasticity makes a steep cut wasteful.
  • Single deep cut (velocity argument): Competera also frames a single deep cut as the practical choice when selling time is short, because adjustments can still be made if the first cut proves deeper than needed. When end-of-season inventory must move in a narrow window, the speed of clearing stock can outweigh the margin cost of an initial over-discount.
  • Product-curve heterogeneity: Markmi (Just-Style 2026-01-20) notes that different products follow different demand curves — a winter coat versus a basic T-shirt — implying no universal rule applies; SKU-level demand modelling is the resolution these vendors pitch.

Evidence gap (2026-11-04): No controlled retailer trial, academic study, or independent benchmarking comparing single deep cut vs. incremental ladder outcomes exists in 2026 sources. The debate is argued entirely from first principles and illustrative examples. This is a genuine evidence gap, not a search failure.

AI / automated vs manual / rules-based

Sources describe a shift from calendar/rules-based markdowns to condition-based, SKU-level optimisation:

  • Trail-ML: dynamic pricing models "combine demand forecasting, Price Elasticity estimation, and constrained optimization to find revenue or margin-maximizing prices subject to business rules," replacing both reactive run-to-failure pricing and fixed calendar schedules (trail-ml, vendor/use-case page, date unknown). Elasticity per product-segment is estimated via causal-inference methods — difference-in-differences, instrumental variables, or randomised price experiments.
  • Beebi: unlike one-size-fits-all rules, products in the same category respond differently — "one SKU may benefit from an earlier, modest intervention. Another may need a deeper price reduction later... A third should remain untouched" (Beebi, snippet only, date unknown).
  • Centric: AI markdown optimisation uses "optimization engines" over sales history, real-time tracking, customer behaviour, market trends and competitor analysis to deliver SKU-level suggestions per channel/location, with adjustable automation and human override (Centric Software, vendor, 2024-06-25).
  • Toolio: moving from spreadsheet-based to purpose-built planning "typically" yields a 5–15% improvement in end-of-season STR (Toolio, vendor) (as-of 2026-06-26).
  • NRF 2026 (official event recap, January 2026): described the retail industry as entering an "agentic" phase of AI deployment in which systems act autonomously to "optimise inventory, enhance customer journeys and power personalised engagement," with NRF 2026 sessions explicitly covering AI-powered autonomous pricing that reacts to demand and competitor pricing in real time (NRF Big Show 2026 recap; Impact Analytics NRF 2026 summary, vendor blog) (as-of 2026-01).
  • IHL Group 2026 Inventory Distortion Study: 76% of retailers using AI/ML for demand planning report positive results (independent research institute; methodology gated; figure covers demand planning broadly, not markdown-specific) (as-of 2026-10-16).

Vendor AI case studies (2025–2026, all low-confidence vendor self-reports)

[!unverified] All figures below are vendor-reported without independent verification, named methodology, or control groups. Record as directional signals only.

  • Increff (sportswear brand, India factory outlet, Feb 2024 vs Feb 2025): sell-through margin +8.6pp (46.1% → 54.7%), markdown depth −7pp (52% → 45%), estimated saving ~€259K. Post-implementation column labeled "Plan," not actuals; brand unnamed.
  • Metyis (luxury/premium European apparel, 2024): up to 4% gross margin uplift; up to 10% sellout rate improvement. No baseline, sample size, or time period given (as-of 2024-05-31, stale-risk).
  • Markmi (C&A, Torfs, European fashion): up to 95% forecast accuracy for 24-week projections; up to ~7% margin improvement during critical sales periods. Markmi raised €1.1M seed funding (FashionUnited, April 2025). (as-of 2026-01-20).
  • Pricen benchmark (mid-market non-food retail, 2026): year-one gross margin lift 4–8%; payback 6–18 months; markdown-led deployments reported to pay back fastest. Illustrative model for a €600M retailer: year-one conservative net benefit €3.4M → best case €7.7M, after costs ~€340K. Year-two results "usually larger," but implementation overruns and stalled adoption cited as ROI risks.

[!unverified] Aggregator/snippet figures not fetched at source: AI improving markdown performance "by an average of 26%," a fashion retailer "saving $32 million annually through reduced terminal markdowns," and AI cutting markdown depth 5–10% while lifting inventory turnover 10–25% (NetSolutions snippet, date unknown). Single-source, vendor/aggregator, unverified.

Consumer discount-conditioning risk

A structural risk that optimising markdowns addresses but cannot fully offset: shoppers conditioned to wait for discounts reduce full-price sell-through and erode the brand's pricing power over time.

RetailNext 2026 Shopper Sentiment Report (n=1,053 US adults, fielded February 2026, nationally representative, ±3% margin of error, primary research published 2026-03-11):

  • 37.7% of respondents believe buying mostly during big promotions will become the new normal (as-of 2026-02).
  • When asked what they would do if prices rose: 24.1% would wait for sales and 24.3% would switch to cheaper brands — the two most-cited trade-down responses, ahead of reducing impulse purchases (20.6%) and buying fewer non-essentials (20.3%) (as-of 2026-02).
  • 55.9% preferred straightforward price discounts as the most valued retailer offer; loyalty rewards preferred by only 19.8% (as-of 2026-02).

Quicklizard (2026-07-28), citing Simon-Kucher 2026 without reproducing the figures, states that predictable promotional calendars condition shoppers to wait for discounts — supporting the case for irregular, trigger-based markdown timing over fixed seasonal calendars.

The implication for markdown strategy: deep or frequent markdowns, especially on predictable calendars, train shoppers to defer full-price purchase. This feeds back into lower full-price sell-through, requiring more markdowns — a cycle that makes the 50% full-price STR figure above self-reinforcing.

Wholesale / B2B markdown dynamics

In the wholesale channel, markdowns work through a fundamentally different mechanism than in direct retail. Rather than the brand itself marking down items on its own sales floor, retailers ask vendors/brands to share the cost of markdowns through "markdown money" — also called markdown allowances. This is a long-established industry practice that retailers treat as a profit source (SPS Commerce 2026-08-13, citing Sourcing Journal).

How it works (SPS Commerce 2026-08-13):

  • A $60 shirt is marked down to $30 at the retailer
  • The vendor is asked to cover half the markdown gap — $15 per unit
  • The percentage split (the article uses 50%, countered at 30%) is negotiated using the retailer's sell-through data
  • Apparel has only approximately 1–1.5 months at full margin before retailers mark down merchandise (Doyle and Associates, cited by SPS Commerce; original date unknown)

Scale of wholesale deductions (Uphance 2026-06-14, vendor experiential claim):

  • For a $15M apparel brand, wholesale deductions (chargebacks + allowances) "routinely run 2 to 5% of wholesale invoice value"
  • Can consume 8–25% of net wholesale margin
  • Under 1% is achievable with connected EDI/planning systems; above 3% signals a broken workflow

Structural risk in the channel (2026): Saks Global filed for Chapter 11 in January 2026 after extending vendor payment terms to 60–90 days in 2025 and failing to fully clear past-due bills; it emerged mid-2026 as Exemplar Luxury Group with debt cut ~75% to ~$840M. Major creditors included Chanel, Kering, LVMH, Capri, and Richemont (SPS Commerce 2026-08-13; consistent with public court record) (as-of 2026-08-13).

Tariff-driven Incoterms shift: McKinsey/BoF State of Fashion 2026 (secondary via lenewblack.com 2025-12-06) reports that brands are shifting Incoterms from DDP to DAP or FOB — moving the duty and transport burden to US retail partners — as a response to US weighted average tariffs on apparel/footwear reaching 36%, more than double historic norms (as-of 2025-12, stale-risk).

Gap (2026-11-04): No sources found on optimisation software or strategies specifically designed for the brand/vendor side of wholesale markdowns — i.e., how brands decide which retail partners to offer markdown support, at what depth, and when. This appears to be a genuine product/research gap, distinct from the retailer-side optimisation covered elsewhere on this page. See Wholesale Allowances for the mechanics-only angle.

Vendor / tooling landscape

Gartner frames the competitive category as "Unified Price, Promotion, and Markdown Optimization Applications" (Gartner reviews, date unknown) — a useful umbrella for where these tools compete.

  • McKinsey uses a proprietary tool, Periscope Price Advisor, to guide apparel companies through forecasting, markdown, pricing and promotion across the product lifecycle (McKinsey, search snippet, date unknown). McKinsey Periscope was named a Leader in the IDC MarketScape: Worldwide Retail Price Optimization Solutions 2023 Vendor Assessment (McKinsey.com press release, 2023) (as-of 2023).

IDC MarketScape 2023 vendor positions may have shifted significantly by 2025–2026. Use the 2025–2026 edition (US52989825) as the current reference.

  • RELEX Solutions was named a Leader in the IDC MarketScape: Worldwide Retail Price Optimization Solutions 2025–2026 Vendor Assessment (container ID: US52989825, 21 vendors assessed), as announced on 10 December 2025. IDC's VP Ananda Chakravarty stated: "RELEX brings together strong automation and data-driven insights that help retailers make smarter, faster pricing and promotions decisions." RELEX's roadmap is focused on building a unified dashboard integrating base pricing, promotions management, and markdown optimisation (RELEX press release via BusinessWire, 2025-12-10) (as-of 2025-12-10).

This is the 2025–2026 edition. A 2026-only edition may follow; RELEX's position as Leader reflects Q4 2025 assessment.

  • Nextail — AI-native merchandising platform for fashion/apparel (inventory optimisation, allocation, replenishment, SKU-store demand prediction), reporting up to 40% sales growth for brands such as Guess and Gina Tricot (CBInsights company profile / vendor claim, date unknown) — low confidence.
  • Centric Software, Toolio, Markmi — fashion merchandise-planning suites with markdown modules (all vendor sources used above).
  • Increff, Competera, Pricen, Metyis, Quicklizard — markdown/pricing optimisation vendors with 2026 case study content; all vendor self-reported, low-confidence.

Revionics ownership. A WebSearch synthesis stated both "Blue Yonder acquired Revionics in 2020" and "Revionics was acquired by Aptos in 2020." Gartner currently lists the vendor as "Aptos (Revionics)" (gartner.com/reviews/.../aptos-revionics), supporting the Aptos acquisition; the Blue Yonder attribution appears to be a synthesis error (Blue Yonder is a separate pricing/markdown vendor in its own right). Recorded unresolved — verify before treating either as fact.

Margin improvement potential — what McKinsey actually says

McKinsey margin-improvement figures — two documents, two ranges.

  • McKinsey, "Pairing advanced analytics with intuitive tools to transform retail markdown management" (PDF, July 2019): states optimising markdowns through advanced analytics can generate "four to eight percent markdown margin rate improvement" (= 400–800 bps), "potentially worth millions of dollars to the bottom line—with relatively quick time to impact of 12–14 weeks" (McKinsey.com PDF, 2019-07) (as-of 2019-07).
  • McKinsey, "Powerful Pricing: The Next Frontier in Apparel and Fashion Advanced Analytics" (article, December 2018): states analytics-driven pricing brought "a margin and sales lift of three to six percentage points" (= 300–600 bps) for some companies (McKinsey.com, 2018-12-13) (as-of 2018-12-13).

Both are pre-2024 documents. The ranges differ (300–600 vs 400–800 bps) and likely reflect different scopes or retailer samples. Secondary vendor blogs citing "400–800 bps McKinsey" point to the 2019 PDF. No McKinsey 2024–2026 publication refreshing these figures was found (as-of 2026-11-04).

Both McKinsey markdown-margin sources (2018 and 2019) pre-date significant industry shifts: the COVID inventory glut (2020–2022), the subsequent inventory normalisation (2022–2023), the EU ESPR destruction ban (2026), and the proliferation of AI-native markdown tools. These figures may not reflect current attainable outcomes.

Regulatory / structural context (2026)

EU ESPR — destruction ban on unsold textiles (primary-sourced)

The prohibition on destruction of unsold apparel, clothing accessories, and footwear was adopted as a Delegated Regulation and Implementing Regulation on 9 February 2026 under the Ecodesign for Sustainable Products Regulation (ESPR), which itself entered into force on 19 July 2024 (European Commission Environment, 2026-02-09).

In-force dates by company size (European Commission Environment, 2026-07-17):

TierCriteriaIn-force date
Large companiesExceeds at least 2 of 3: >250 employees, >€50M turnover, >€25M total assets19 July 2026
Medium companies50–249 employees, turnover ≤€50M1 January 2030
Small and micro enterprises<50 employees, balance sheet <€10MPermanently exempt

Product scope: apparel, clothing accessories (hats, headgear), and footwear of all materials. (as-of 2026-07-17)

Permitted exceptions — destruction is allowed only when items are (European Commission Environment, 2026-07-17):

  • Unsafe or severely damaged
  • Non-compliant with EU or national law
  • Counterfeit or IP-infringing
  • Rejected by charities or donation schemes

All exceptions must be documented. Companies must retain records for five years to allow national authority inspections.

Disclosure: standardised format for reporting volumes of unsold goods discarded applies from February 2027 (European Commission Environment, 2026-02-09).

Scale context: the Commission estimates 250,000–600,000 tonnes of unsold clothing are destroyed annually in Europe, representing 4–9% of total garments placed on the EU market (as-of 2026-07-17) (European Commission Environment, 2026-07-17).

Implication for markdown strategy: with destruction no longer available as a terminal inventory clearance route for large EU fashion companies, units that previously might have been destroyed must now be sold, donated, or repurposed — structurally changing the floor on clearance markdown depth.

Tariff-driven overstock risk (2026)

IHL Group's 2026 Inventory Distortion Study (last modified 2026-10-16) estimates global inventory distortion (combined overstock and stockout) at approximately $1.7–1.73T/year, equivalent to 6.2–6.5% of global retail sales — improved from 10.4% of retail sales in 2021, a five-year trend of improvement. However, IHL flags two new forces now threatening that improvement: tariff-driven panic buying and a sharp drop in consumer confidence (as-of 2026-10-16).

The tariff channel is structural: US weighted average tariffs on apparel/footwear reportedly reached 36% in 2026 (McKinsey/BoF State of Fashion 2026, secondary cite), more than double historic norms. If brands pulled forward orders to beat tariff implementation — a common panic-buying pattern — the resulting overstock would arrive in US retail channels mid-to-late 2026, with pressure to clear through deeper or earlier markdowns. This risk is flagged by IHL but not yet quantified in publicly available 2026 research (as-of 2026-10-16).

Supply chain context: Markmi reports supply-chain lead times of approximately ~67 days (Markmi, vendor, 2026) (as-of 2026-06-26).

[!unverified] The "~67 day" lead time doubling figure is vendor-stated (Markmi) and not independently corroborated.

The US online apparel return rate is approximately 24.4% (Eightx 2026-06-08, attributing Coresight Research, "The True Cost of Apparel Returns"), with discount-driven buyers returning at higher rates than full-price buyers — implying markdowns should be modelled on net units after returns. See Returns Management (as-of 2026-06-26).

Market sizing: the global retail pricing software market was "valued at ~USD 3.2bn in 2023, projected to reach ~USD 7.8bn by 2033" (DataHorizzon Research, date unknown). 2023 base year, low confidence.

Key terms

TermMeaning (as sources use it)
MarkdownA permanent price reduction to clear inventory (vs a temporary promotion)
Markdown ladderThe sequence of discount percentages a style steps through over a season (Centric)
Terminal / clearance markdownThe final, deepest cut to exit remaining stock, floored at landed cost + min margin (Toolio)
Sell-through triggerMarking down based on a style falling below its sell-through curve rather than a calendar date (Eightx)
Markdown reserve / budgetThe planned markdown allowance carried in Merchandise Financial Planning (MFP) / Open-to-Buy (OTB)
Markdown money / allowanceIn wholesale, a vendor payment to the retailer to cover part of the cost of a retail markdown (SPS Commerce)

What practitioners report

Gap (2026-11-04): Reddit MCP unavailable in Cowork cloud (known recurring gap — reddit-research MCP tools not present in this environment). Apify YouTube transcripts unavailable (known recurring gap — Apify tools not present). Gaps filled this run: named-practitioner corroboration of 50% sell-through (Mountford/Hunkemöller); consumer conditioning data (RetailNext 2026 primary, n=1,053); wholesale markdown allowance mechanics (SPS Commerce 2026); tariff-driven overstock risk flag (IHL 2026). Gaps remaining unfilled: empirical head-to-head comparison of one deep cut vs. incremental ladder (genuine evidence gap — no controlled data exists); independent small-retailer ROI (<€50M or <20 doors); wholesale-side optimisation tools (how brands decide which retailers receive markdown support). Five YouTube videos from NRF 2026 and PI Apparel sessions identified in 2026-08-08 run remain unread (Apify required). See YouTube — Markdown Optimisation 2026-08-08 for the video list.

Research agent · 2026-06-26