On this page
- What it is: Section 1033 and the CFPB Rule
- Regulatory timeline (as-of 2026-10-31)
- The fee ban controversy
- Private bilateral deals: filling the regulatory vacuum
- US open banking at checkout: the infrastructure layer
- US payment rail landscape (as-of 2026)
- A2A payments and ecommerce relevance
- Global benchmarks (as-of 2025-2026)
- US-specific context (as-of 2022–2023 McKinsey baseline)
- Why US A2A adoption lags cards
- US vs. UK/EU comparison
- Key terms
Open Banking (US)
Open Banking (US)
The US version of open banking is built around consumer-permissioned financial data sharing — the right of consumers to authorize third parties (fintechs, aggregators, retailers) to access their bank account data. Unlike the UK and EU, where open banking was driven by regulation (PSD2/Open Banking Standard), the US model evolved market-first through data aggregators like Plaid and Finicity, with the regulatory layer arriving a decade later via Section 1033 of the Dodd-Frank Act. As of late 2026, that regulatory layer remains enjoined in federal court while the CFPB rewrites it, leaving the market in a fragmented state of private bilateral API deals and competing state-level legislation.
What it is: Section 1033 and the CFPB Rule
Section 1033 of the Dodd-Frank Act (2010) gave consumers the right to access their own financial data — but the CFPB did not issue an implementing rule until October 2024. The CFPB's "Personal Financial Data Rights" rule, finalized under Director Rohit Chopra, required covered financial institutions to make consumer financial data electronically available to consumers and authorized third parties. (American Banker, 2025-10-29)
Covered entities: depository institutions with ≥$850 million in assets and certain nonbanks. (Congressional Research Service, 2025-09-30)
Covered data: past 24 months of transactions, account terms and conditions, and personal account information. (CRS, 2025-09-30)
Third-party obligations (original rule): data collection limited to ≤1 year; GLBA data security requirements; data use restricted to "reasonably necessary" purposes. (CRS, 2025-09-30)
Regulatory timeline (as-of 2026-10-31)
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| Oct 2024 | CFPB finalizes Section 1033 rule |
| 2024 | Forcht Bank, Bank Policy Institute, and Kentucky Bankers Association file suit (APA; exceeds statutory authority) |
| Aug 2025 | CFPB publishes ANPR with 36 questions on security, fee ban, definitions; 13,979 comment letters received |
| Oct 29, 2025 | U.S. District Judge Danny C. Reeves (ED Kentucky) issues preliminary injunction — compliance halted while CFPB rewrites rule |
| Dec 2025 | CFPB files joint status report: plans interim final rule via APA "good cause" exception |
| Apr 1, 2026 | Original compliance deadline for largest banks passes with rule still enjoined |
| Apr 2026 | Sixth Circuit pauses all appeals pending new rulemaking; CFPB operating with skeleton staff |
| Jun 2026 | State-level open banking legislation in focus as federal gap-filler (Consumer Finance Monitor, 2026-06) |
| Aug 2026 | Revised Section 1033 proposal reportedly sent to White House for review (The Paypers, 2026 — single source, unverified primary) |
Compliance deadline ambiguity (as-of 2026): The American Banker (2026-04-02) describes April 1, 2026 as "the original compliance deadline." The American Banker (2025-10-29) references June 30, 2026. The CRS report (2025-09-30) states April 2026 for the largest banks. These likely refer to different compliance tiers — April for the very largest institutions, June 30 for the first general tier — but the CFPB's own framing shifted as litigation progressed. [American Banker 2026-04-02] vs [American Banker 2025-10-29]
The fee ban controversy
The original rule barred covered data providers from charging aggregators fees for API access. The CFPB estimated annual compliance costs at up to $47 million. (American Banker, 2025-10-29)
Banks (led by the ABA) argue fees are necessary to recover infrastructure costs. The Financial Technology Association argues data-access tolls could price aggregators out and harm consumer choice. The CFPB ANPR specifically questioned the fee ban. (American Banker, 2026-04-02)
JPMorgan Chase is already charging data aggregators for access — analysts estimate roughly $300 million per year in fee revenue from the bank's approximately 1.89 billion monthly data requests. (Pulse.bot, 2026)
Fee ban vs. bilateral fee-charging in practice (as-of 2026): The original 2024 rule banned data-access fees; however, with the rule enjoined, banks have implemented fees in bilateral agreements, pre-empting any regulated outcome. Whether the revised rule will reinstate the ban is unknown. [American Banker 2026-04-02] vs [Pulse.bot 2026]
Private bilateral deals: filling the regulatory vacuum
With the federal mandate stalled, major banks and aggregators have negotiated direct API data-sharing agreements (American Banker, 2026-04-02):
- Truist Financial ($548B assets): partnered with Plaid for API-based bank verification
- JPMorgan Chase, Wells Fargo, Citi: signed API deals with aggregators
- Wells Fargo and PNC: issued cease-and-desist letters to Trustly (Oct/Nov 2025) for screen-scraping customer credentials
At least 100 million US consumers had authorized third-party data access as of 2024, per CFPB data cited by the Congressional Research Service. (CRS, 2025-09-30)
The 100M figure cites 2024 CFPB data via a 2025 CRS report — potentially superseded by 2026 actuals.
Card network moves: Mastercard acquired Finicity and Visa acquired Tink to expand open banking data-sharing capabilities in the US and Europe respectively. (McKinsey, undated — likely 2023)
Retailers and fintechs pressed President Trump to preserve Rule 1033, signalling that pro-commerce interests diverge from incumbent banking groups opposing it. (PYMNTS, 2025-2026)
US banks and fintechs clashing over "exorbitant" open banking access fees charged by financial institutions for API connectivity was highlighted by VIXIO regulatory intelligence (2026).
US open banking at checkout: the infrastructure layer
Plaid: Dominant US financial data aggregator; connects consumer bank accounts to third-party apps. At least 75% of Plaid's traffic was on or committed to APIs as of ~2023 (Finextra, ~2023 — stale-risk); bilateral fee dispute with JPMorgan ongoing as of 2026.
Stripe Financial Connections (as-of 2026-10-28): Supports instant bank account verification for US bank accounts from 12,000+ institutions via OAuth or credential-based flows; default bank account verification method for Stripe-hosted ACH flows (Checkout, Payment Element, Hosted Invoicing). Added Plaid processor token support on 2026-10-28 as an alternative to microdeposits. (Stripe Docs / Changelog, 2026)
Stripe Pay by Bank: Available in the UK (launched May 2024) and PayTo in Australia (Dec 2025); no equivalent US bank payment product as of October 2026. (Stripe Blog, 2024-05-21 / 2025-12-15)
Adyen (as-of 2026-06-02): Routes open banking bank data traffic through Tink, Yapily, and Plaid based on coverage, conversion, performance, cost, and fraud rates. Adyen's open banking article (June 2026) contains no US-specific content, no references to Section 1033 or CFPB. (Adyen Knowledge Hub, 2026-06-02)
Checkout.com (as-of 2026-08-26): Lists open banking as "coming soon" on its platform; ACH, FedNow, and RTP described as the primary US interbank payment rails. (Checkout.com, 2026-08-26)
US payment rail landscape (as-of 2026)
| Rail | Settlement | Key characteristic |
|---|---|---|
| ACH Credit/Debit | 1–2 business days (same-day available) | Most common US bank payment; most familiar to merchants |
| FedNow | Instant, 24/7 | Transaction limit raised to $10M in 2026; no reversal rights |
| RTP (The Clearing House) | Instant, 24/7 | Matches FedNow's $10M cap; no reversal rights |
FedNow raised its transaction limit to $10 million in 2026, matching The Clearing House's RTP network. (The Paypers, 2026)
A2A payments and ecommerce relevance
Open banking is the primary enabler of A2A Payments — direct bank-to-bank transfers at checkout that bypass card networks and their interchange fees.
Global benchmarks (as-of 2025-2026)
- A2A: 7% of global ecommerce value and 4% of global POS value in 2025 (Worldpay GPR 2026, cited by The Paypers, 2026)
- Digital wallets: 56% of global online spending (Worldpay GPR 2026)
- Juniper Research forecast: global A2A value $91.5 trillion (2025) → $195 trillion (2030, ~16% CAGR) — mostly B2B; consumer A2A $1.7 trillion (2024) → $5.7 trillion (2029, ~27% CAGR) (The Paypers, 2026)
Worldpay GPR 2026 and Juniper Research figures are cited via The Paypers (2026); primary Worldpay GPR 2026 is in the report queue for ingestion.
US-specific context (as-of 2022–2023 McKinsey baseline)
- US digital commerce spend (2022): cards = $2.5T+; A2A/alternatives = $160B (McKinsey, undated ~2023)
- Cards forecast ~90% of US digital payments through 2027 (McKinsey, undated ~2023)
- US A2A consumer remote POS purchases forecast to exceed $200B by 2026–2027, ~19% CAGR, ~5% of US digital commerce (McKinsey)
McKinsey figures use 2022 as baseline; publication date unclear (likely 2023). May be superseded by 2025–2026 actuals.
McKinsey A2A volume figure: The McKinsey article references $200 billion as both a 2026 figure and a 2027 figure in different places; the article itself acknowledges the conflict. [McKinsey, undated]
Why US A2A adoption lags cards
- Consumers lose card fraud protections, credit float, and rewards when using A2A (McKinsey)
- Checkout friction: consumers must enter bank credentials vs. saved card or wallet (McKinsey)
- Dispute process: FedNow and RTP have no reversal rights; no credit card chargeback equivalent (Checkout.com, 2026-08-26)
- Interchange economics: card MDR typically 2.0–3.5%; A2A API fee ~40–50 cents per call; regulated debit capped ~25 cents — A2A cost-competitive primarily at high ticket values (McKinsey, ~2023)
The merchant incentive for A2A is lower interchange: PYMNTS reported open banking-powered payments could offer US merchants relief from interchange fees (PYMNTS, 2024 — stale-risk).
FF News cited a 2025 industry report describing pay-by-bank as "table stakes for banks and PSPs as merchant demand and confidence surges" — vendor/trade framing, flag for bias. (FF News, 2025)
US vs. UK/EU comparison
| Dimension | US | UK | EU |
|---|---|---|---|
| Driver | Market-first aggregators; regulation lagging | Regulation-first (PSD2 / Open Banking Order 2017) | Regulation-first (PSD2) |
| Primary framework | Section 1033 / CFPB rule (enjoined Oct 2025) | Open Banking Standard (FCA) | PSD2 → PSD3 (Payment Services Directive 3) |
| Status (Oct 2026) | Enjoined; rewrite in progress | Established; VRP commercial scheme live Jun 2026 | PSD3/PSR texts published Apr 2026; compliance ~2028 |
| Data layer | Aggregators (Plaid, Finicity, MX, Yodlee) | Open Banking Ltd API standard | Banks per PSD2 mandate |
| A2A growth | ACH + early FedNow; A2A ~5% digital commerce | 53% growth in 2025; VRP expanding use cases | Varies by market |
| Card dominance | ~90% digital commerce (2022 baseline) | High but declining | High but declining |
UK Open Banking payments grew 53% in 2025; the UK's first commercial VRP scheme launched June 2, 2026. EU PSD3/PSR final texts published April 23, 2026, compliance target ~late 2028. (The Paypers, 2026)
Key terms
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Section 1033 | Dodd-Frank Act provision giving consumers the right to access their own financial data |
| CFPB | Consumer Financial Protection Bureau — US regulator that wrote the implementing rule |
| ANPR | Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking — preliminary step before a formal rule |
| A2A | Account-to-Account payment — direct bank-to-bank transfer bypassing card networks |
| Screen scraping | Older aggregation method where aggregators log in as the consumer; being phased out in favor of APIs |
| Data aggregator | Intermediary (Plaid, Finicity, MX) that connects consumer bank accounts to third-party apps via API |
| FedNow | Federal Reserve's instant payment rail, launched 2023; $10M transaction limit (as-of 2026) |
| RTP | Real-Time Payments network run by The Clearing House; competitor to FedNow |
| Pay by Bank | Checkout option where consumers pay directly from their bank account, bypassing card networks |
| VRP | Variable Recurring Payments — open banking-enabled recurring payments; live UK commercial scheme Jun 2026 |
| Bilateral API deal | Direct data-sharing agreement between a bank and an aggregator, negotiated without regulatory mandate |