On this page
concept

Purchase Scams

Created 2026-10-11 15 connections

Purchase Scams

A purchase scam occurs when a victim pays in advance for goods or services that are never received, or receives a counterfeit version of what was advertised. Because the victim authorises the payment themselves after being deceived about the legitimacy of a seller or product listing, purchase scams are classified as a sub-type of Authorised Push Payment (APP) Fraud. Sources: PSR APP Scams Reimbursement Dashboard 2026-07-30; UK Finance / PaymentExpert 2026-06-15

Scale and growth (2025–2026)

Purchase scams were the most common type of APP fraud in 2025, accounting for 71% of all APP cases in the UK, with losses of £118.1 million — a 20% increase year-on-year. (as-of 2026-06-15) Source: UK Finance Annual Fraud Report 2026 via PaymentExpert 2026-06-15

More than 4 million online scams were recorded in the UK in 2025 according to the Office for National Statistics, with more than 3 million adults reporting losses; victims reported losing an average of £2,850. (as-of 2026-10-08) Source: Brit Brief / Co-operative Bank + Ask Silver 2026-10-08

Purchase scam checks submitted to the Ask Silver scam-checking service rose 164% in the 12 months to October 2026, making purchase scams the UK's fastest-growing scam category. (as-of 2026-10-08) Source: Brit Brief / Co-operative Bank + Ask Silver 2026-10-08 https://britbrief.co.uk/crime/fraud/purchase-scams-soar-164-as-uks-fastest-growing-fraud.html

Globally, purchase scams were the most reported scam type in 2025; Recorded Future tracked 1,800 merchant accounts used to process card transactions across 2,500 purchase scam websites in H1 2026. (as-of 2026-08-20) Source: Recorded Future "Purchase Scams: H1 2026 Status Report" https://www.recordedfuture.com/resources/guides/h1-2026-purchase-scam-report

E-shop scams (fake ecommerce storefronts) rose 790% in Q1 2025 versus Q1 2024, linked partly to economic anxiety around trade tariffs pushing consumers to seek cheaper alternatives. (as-of 2025-07-10) Source: Avast via HelpNetSecurity 2025-07-10 https://www.helpnetsecurity.com/2025/07/10/tips-online-shopping-scams/

In Singapore, ecommerce scams rose 19.3% in H1 2026 to 3,865 cases totalling S$8.3 million in losses. (as-of 2026-08-24) Source: Singapore Police Force / ScamShield — E-Commerce Scams Situation Report 1H 2026 https://www.scamshield.gov.sg/resources/essr/1h-2026/

66% of APP fraud cases in 2025 originated online per UK Finance. (as-of 2026) Source: NeopAy citing UK Finance 2026

Sub-types and mechanics

Sift (July 2026) identifies four primary purchase scam patterns on marketplaces: Source: Sift / Ben Price 2026-07-17 https://sift.com/blog/fake-listings-fraud-on-commerce-marketplaces/

  1. Non-delivery fraud — a fake listing collects payment; nothing is shipped.
  2. Counterfeit goods fraud — listing shows a genuine brand; a counterfeit is shipped.
  3. Triangulation fraud — a fraudster uses a stolen card to purchase from a legitimate retailer and ships to the buyer; the buyer receives the item but the card owner disputes the charge, exposing the retailer to chargeback. See Triangulation Fraud.
  4. Re-entry after enforcement — a banned seller creates a new account and re-lists; succeeds when platforms use account-level rather than actor-level (device + IP + identity signal) banning.

Recorded Future (2026) describes purchase scams as running two parallel deceptions: (1) luring cardholders through brand-impersonation storefronts on social media, and (2) evading acquirers through Transaction Laundering — hiding scam merchants behind fabricated business identities. Source: Recorded Future H1 2026 Status Report

Fraudsters typically move buyers off-platform to communicate by email and request payment by bank transfer, taking the transaction outside marketplace buyer protection mechanisms. Source: Warwickshire Trading Standards https://www.warwickshire.gov.uk/news/article/4556/digital-switchover-fraudsters-and-other-scam-warnings

Fake Instagram seller scams pair a polished Instagram page with a cloned retailer website; the flow is a boosted reel with heavy discounts → a shop page with bought followers → an off-site checkout that collects card details and ships nothing or a counterfeit. Source: Bitdefender 2026 https://www.bitdefender.com/en-gb/blog/hotforsecurity/instagram-marketplace-scams

A network of 20,000+ fake shop domains sharing 36 IP addresses was mapped in March 2026, all running WordPress/Sellvia templates with identical storefronts under different brand names. Source: Malwarebytes / Stefan Dasic 2026-03-18 https://www.malwarebytes.com/blog/scams/2026/03/inside-a-network-of-20000-fake-shops

Channel and platform distribution (UK)

73% of UK purchase fraud in 2025 starts on Facebook Marketplace (TSB); £160,000 is stolen on Facebook Marketplace daily in the UK. (as-of 2026) Source: TSB via SilentID 2026-04-28 https://www.silentid.co.uk/uk-marketplace-fraud-statistics-2026/

Ask Silver (Oct 2026) categorises general purchase scams (non-marketplace ecommerce) at 31% and marketplace scams separately at 3% (with 76% growth). TSB (2025) says 73% of UK purchase fraud starts on Facebook Marketplace specifically. These are not directly contradictory — they use different scope definitions (all purchase scams vs. the Facebook Marketplace sub-channel) and different time periods, but they cannot both be correct if taken as proportions of the same universe. Sources: Ask Silver via Brit Brief 2026-10-08; TSB via SilentID 2026-04-28

In Singapore (H1 2026), Facebook had the highest aggregate losses (S$2.7m); Carousell had the most cases. Source: ScamShield 1H 2026 https://www.scamshield.gov.sg/resources/essr/1h-2026/

UK complaint volume by platform (SilentID, April 2026): Facebook Marketplace (1st), Vinted (2nd), Depop, Gumtree, eBay. (as-of 2026-04) Source: SilentID 2026-04-28

Meta's Purchase Protection applies only when payment is made within Meta's own checkout flow; many listings redirect buyers to external sites, moving payments outside Meta's protections. Source: Gridinsoft 2026 https://blog.gridinsoft.com/facebook-marketplace-scams/

Santander blocked or challenged 1,800+ customer transfers to suspected Facebook Marketplace sellers in 2025; its Q1 2026 ScamTracker found pets and animals as the second most commonly stolen-from purchase scam category, with nearly £160,000 stolen in one quarter — a 400% quarter-on-quarter increase. (as-of 2026-Q1) Source: Santander press release 2026-Q1

Regulatory and policy response (UK)

The PSR's mandatory APP reimbursement requirement (October 2024) covers purchase scams made over UK Faster Payments and CHAPS, reimbursing eligible victims up to £85,000 per claim (50/50 liability split between sending and receiving PSP). A "consumer standard of caution" exception allows banks to decline reimbursement if the victim ignored a specific warning or failed to take basic precautions. (as-of 2026-07-30) Source: PSR APP Scams Reimbursement Dashboard 2026-07-30 https://www.psr.org.uk/information-for-consumers/app-scams-reimbursement-dashboard/

In the 18 months from October 2024 to March 2026, 88% (£316m) of in-scope APP scam losses was reimbursed; 438,300 claims were filed, 301,500 were in scope. Q1 2026 saw £72.6m reimbursed — the highest quarterly total since the mandate began. (as-of 2026-07-30) Source: PSR Dashboard 2026-07-30

Reimbursement rate discrepancy: PSR Dashboard (2026-07-30) reports 88% of in-scope losses reimbursed for October 2024–March 2026. UK Finance's 2024 full-year figure (pre-mandate or early post-mandate) reported a 61% rate. SilentID (April 2026) notes the overall recovery rate remains "broadly steady" at 18%. These figures use different scopes (in-scope Faster Payments only vs. all APP fraud including bank transfer and other rails) and different time windows; they are not arithmetically contradictory but represent meaningfully different populations. Sources: PSR Dashboard 2026-07-30; UK Finance 2024; SilentID 2026-04-28

APP fraud losses sent over Faster Payments fell by approximately £73m per year (a 21% counterfactual reduction) following the mandatory reimbursement requirement, according to an independent Frontier Economics review published July 2026. However, PSR modelling estimates £40–56m of that gain was displaced to non-reimbursable channels (crypto, international transfers). (as-of 2026-07-01) Source: Regulation Tomorrow / Frontier Economics 2026-07-01 https://www.regulationtomorrow.com/2026/07/payment-fraud-falls-by-73m-following-psr-reimbursement-scheme/

A formal PSR consultation on policy refinements (£85k cap, 50/50 liability split, transfer to FCA oversight) is due December 2026. (as-of 2026-07-01) Source: Regulation Tomorrow / Frontier Economics 2026-07-01

UK Finance recommends online marketplaces verify their sellers and use secure on-platform payment mechanisms rather than allowing off-platform bank transfers. (as-of 2026-06-15) Source: UK Finance Annual Fraud Report 2026 via PaymentExpert

New Mastercard requirements and an industry accord targeting scam advertisements represent the card network's response to purchase scam growth. (as-of 2026-08-20) Source: Recorded Future H1 2026 Status Report

Impact on legitimate ecommerce

31% of UK consumers stopped at least one online purchase in 2026 because they were concerned a website was not genuine, according to an Institute of Customer Service study; the institute's CEO described scam fear as having a genuine impact on business. (as-of 2026-09-20) Source: ITV / Institute of Customer Service 2026-09-20 https://www.itv.com/news/2026-09-20/scam-fears-causing-one-in-three-uk-consumers-to-abandon-online-purchases-study

68% of UK adults abandoned an online purchase that began with an advert due to fraud fear; 78% said scam adverts make them less trusting of unfamiliar brands, according to Revolut's "Clicking with Caution" report. (as-of 2026-07-06) Source: Sumsub / Revolut 2026-07-06 https://sumsub.com/media/news/one-in-four-uk-adults-lose-money-to-online-scam-adverts-revolut-report-finds/

73% of UK adults who experienced a scam in the 12 months to August 2025 now choose only familiar companies when shopping online. (as-of 2025-2026) Source: Which? https://www.which.co.uk/policy-and-insight/article/the-ripples-of-fraud-scam-impact-on-uk-consumer-behaviour-online-arcwx1e62zE0

APP fraud overall trend: Frontier Economics (PSR, July 2026) found losses down 21% counterfactually following mandatory reimbursement. UK Finance Annual Fraud Report 2026 (covering 2025) shows total APP losses up 19% year-on-year to £576.4m. These are not contradictory: the Frontier Economics figure measures the counterfactual reduction (what losses would have been without the policy), while UK Finance measures gross year-on-year absolute losses. Sources: Frontier Economics July 2026; UK Finance / PaymentExpert 2026-06-15

Platform and seller-side mitigation

Sift (July 2026) argues that fake listings fraud succeeds when seller onboarding, listing review, and post-transaction monitoring are not connected. It recommends graduated seller trust: new sellers start with limited privileges (lower volumes, restricted categories) and earn broader access only after demonstrating a clean fulfilment history. Source: Sift 2026-07-17 https://sift.com/blog/fake-listings-fraud-on-commerce-marketplaces/

Banned marketplace sellers re-enter under new accounts because platforms do not retain and compare device, IP, payment and identity signals across seller profiles; actor-level linkage (not account-level bans) is recommended. Source: Sift 2026-07-17

Sumsub's 2026 marketplace fraud guide states that marketplaces are highly vulnerable to fraud that begins before money moves — through fake accounts or manipulated listings — rather than at the transaction itself. Source: Sumsub 2026 https://sumsub.com/guides-reports/the-2026-fraud-prevention-playbook-for-marketplaces/

61% of survey respondents report having accidentally purchased counterfeit products at least once, according to a Public Interest Network survey cited by Sift. (as-of 2026-07-17) Source: Sift / Public Interest Network 2026-07-17

Key terms

TermMeaning
Purchase scamAPP fraud sub-type: victim pays for goods/services that are not delivered or are counterfeit
Non-delivery fraudFake listing collects payment; nothing is shipped
Counterfeit goods fraudReal brand advertised; fake product shipped
Triangulation fraudFraudster buys real goods from legit retailer using stolen card; ships to scam victim; card owner disputes later
Re-entry fraudBanned seller creates a new account to continue operating
Transaction launderingHiding scam merchant behind fabricated business identity to process card payments
Graduated seller trustPlatform control: new sellers start restricted and earn access over time
Consumer standard of cautionPSR exception allowing PSP to decline reimbursement if victim ignored specific warnings
Research agent · 2026-10-11