On this page
concept

Return Rate Benchmarks

Created 2026-09-24 15 connections

Return Rate Benchmarks

The share of sold items sent back by customers — one of the most significant cost and margin variables in ecommerce, particularly in fashion. Return rates are highly sensitive to category, channel, geography, price point, and return policy structure. Online return rates are structurally higher than in-store rates because customers cannot inspect items before purchase.

Overall ecommerce rate (2025–2026)

The National Retail Federation (NRF), co-publishing with Happy Returns and UPS in October 2025, put the online-only return rate at 19.3% for 2025, against a blended all-retail return rate of 15.8% (totalling $849.9 billion) (NRF/Happy Returns/UPS, 2025-10-15). A CNBC broadcast citing the same NRF data reported "almost 16% of total 2025 retail purchases will be returned... worth $850 billion" and that "it will cost retail $75 billion" (CNBC Television, 2025-12-30).

Aggregated industry benchmarks from multiple sources (citing Capital One Shopping, eFulfillment Service, and others) cluster around 20–21% for pure ecommerce in 2026 (as-of 2026-09-21), versus 8.72% for physical stores (Ringly.io citing Capital One Shopping, 2026-09-21).

Online return rate — denominator confusion. NRF publishes two figures from the same dataset: 15.8% (all retail channels combined) and 19.3% (online-only). Aggregators — including Eightx, Ringly.io, and Synctrack — frequently cite 19.3% or higher (20–21%) for the online channel, while some reports round the blended figure up. Always confirm whether a headline figure is channel-specific or blended. [NRF/Happy Returns 2025-10-15 vs Ringly.io 2026-09-21]

Historical trend (US)

Return rates have fluctuated significantly since 2019 (Synctrack, updated 2026-07-21, citing NRF data series):

YearReturn rate (all retail)
20198.1%
202010.6%
202116.6% (pandemic peak)
202314.5%
202416.9%
202515.8% (blended) / 19.3% (online-only)

NRF reported that online return rates increased 39.2% between 2023 and 2024, before easing slightly in 2025 (as-of 2026-09-21) (Ringly.io citing NRF).

By category

Return rates vary sharply by product type. The following ranges consolidate multiple industry sources (Ringly.io citing Mailmodo and Red Stag Fulfillment, 2026-09-21; Synctrack, 2026-07-21; Richpanel, 2026):

CategoryReturn rate range
Fashion / apparel20–30% (luxury fashion up to 50%)
Online apparel (US)22% per ICC survey (CNBC, 2025-12-30)
Online apparel (UK)~23.6% of ecommerce orders (ZigZag × Retail Economics, cited in Eightx, 2026-06-12)
Fashion (Germany)~44% due to widespread Bracketing (Fashion Returns) (Synctrack citing LogisticsMatter, 2026-07-21)
Footwear17–30%
Electronics8–15%
Home / furniture15–20%
Accessories~12%
Beauty / personal care1–12% (see contradiction below)

Beauty return rate range. Synctrack/Richpanel reports 1–5%; Ringly.io (citing Red Stag Fulfillment) gives 4–10%; Eightx UK benchmark reports ~12% for UK beauty. The wider UK range may reflect a broader category definition that includes personal care devices. No primary source reconciles these figures.

Blue Yonder CEO Duncan Groves noted in a December 2025 CNBC segment: "If you're in apparel and one third of your inventory is being returned, that's basically your largest supplier that you're not managing" (CNBC Television, 2025-12-30). He also stated that "almost a third [of returned inventory] doesn't go back on sale. It goes into a landfill."

By channel

Channel significantly influences return rates (Eightx 2026 H1 portfolio data, 2026-03-12 — vendor portfolio, not a broad industry survey):

ChannelReturn rate (as-of 2026-03-12)
DTC direct14.8%
Marketplace19.1%
Social commerce (in-app)23.7%
DTC apparel median22.4%

Social commerce in-app purchases face structurally high return rates due to impulse-purchase dynamics; live-stream shopping is reported to have lower returns because "you're investing time and space in there" (EMARKETER, 2025-01-22). Social commerce in-app returns also face a structural friction: "If you're on Instagram and go to Macy's website you return to Macy's, but if you're checking out in the app that's a different situation" (EMARKETER, 2025-01-22).

By geography

MarketOnline return rateNotes
US19.3% (online-only, 2025)NRF/Happy Returns 2025-10-15
UK non-food online~19.5% (2025 est.)Eightx 2026-06-12 (citing ONS + ZigZag)
UK clothing online~23.6%ZigZag × Retail Economics (via Eightx)
Europe (general)25–40%Synctrack citing LogisticsMatter, 2026-07-21
Germany fashion~44%Bracketing culture (Synctrack, 2026-07-21)
China~60%Frictionless free-return policies (Reuters via Synctrack)

The ONS internet-sales ratio placed UK online commerce at 27.3% of total UK retail in April 2026 (series J4MC/DRSI, confirmed primary, via Eightx, 2026-06-12).

"Returnuary" — the January returns surge following holiday gifting — totalled an estimated £1.55 billion of goods returned in January 2026 in the UK, up from £1.51 billion the prior year (Green Fulfilment, 2026-01, referenced in search results; URL not directly fetched).

IMRG UK public figures date to ~2019–2020: UK overall 15–17%, womenswear 23%, footwear 20%, beauty 4%. Current IMRG data is gated behind membership. These historical figures may not reflect current UK conditions.

Cost benchmarks

Returns consume significant margin across the supply chain (as-of 2026-09-21):

  • Per-return processing cost (US): $10–$65; average $20–$30 (Ringly.io citing WiserReview/Opensend, 2026-09-21)
  • As share of item value: 20–65% of the item's original price (CNBC Television, 2025-12-30; Ringly.io citing Opensend)
  • Return shipping alone: $8–$12 before inspection and restocking (Ringly.io citing Opensend)
  • UK per-return cost: approximately £10–£25 for a £50 DTC order (Eightx worked example, 2026-06-12, citing nShift, Landmark Global, Savills, ReBound — illustrative, not a measured average)
  • Unsaleable inventory: over 30% of returned items cannot be resold as new (Ringly.io citing Gitnux, 2026-09-21); CNBC/Blue Yonder: "almost a third goes into a landfill" (2025-12-30)
  • Total US cost: approximately $75 billion in retailer costs for 2025 (CNBC Television citing NRF/Blue Yonder data, 2025-12-30)

Blue Yonder CEO Duncan Groves reported: "Retailers that have one person who owns returns see double-digit improvements in gross margin" (CNBC Television, 2025-12-30).

Environmental cost: 9.5 billion pounds of returned goods enter US landfills annually; ecommerce returns generate 24 million metric tons of CO2 per year (Ringly.io citing Optoro, 2026-09-21).

Consumer behaviour drivers

Sizing, fit, and colour issues account for 45% of all retail returns; 16% arrive damaged; 14% result from inaccurate product descriptions (as-of 2026-09-21) (Ringly.io citing Mailmodo).

Bracketing is widespread: 63% of consumers admit buying multiple sizes or variations intending to keep one (Ringly.io citing Returnalyze/ReadyCloud, 2026-09-21); 30% of online shoppers intentionally overbuy. See Bracketing (Fashion Returns).

Generational pattern: Gen Z consumers (ages 18–30) averaged 7.7 online returns in the last 12 months — more than any other generation (as-of 2025-10-15) (NRF/Happy Returns).

Holiday: retailers expect 17% of holiday sales to be returned, consistent year over year (NRF, 2025-10-15). $181 billion in online purchases were returned November–December 2025 (14% of holiday purchases, up 10% year-over-year — Ringly.io citing Digital Commerce 360, 2026-09-21).

As of early 2026, 65.2% of merchants charge fees for mail-in returns; average return fee is $9.04 (as-of 2026-09-21) (Ringly.io citing eFulfillment Service). The number of brands charging for returns rose 6% year-over-year, marking the fourth consecutive annual increase (CNBC Television, 2025-12-30).

In the UK, 35% of the top 100 fashion retailers charged for returns as of 2026, up from 23% in 2023; 66.1% of UK merchants overall have introduced return fees (referenced via Ingrid.com in search results; URL not directly fetched).

Consumer sentiment remains strongly pro-free-returns: 82% say free returns are important when deciding where to shop (up from 76% in 2024); 71% say a bad returns experience would stop them shopping with a retailer again (up from 67%) (NRF/Happy Returns, 2025-10-15).

51% of merchants offer incentives (average $11.28) to encourage exchanges over refunds (as-of 2026-09-21) (Ringly.io citing eFulfillment Service).

Returns fraud

9% of all returns are estimated to involve fraud (as-of 2025-10-15) (NRF/Happy Returns); broader fraud-and-abuse figures reach 15.1% of total return volume (Ringly.io citing WiserReview/NRF, 2026-09-21). Returns fraud costs US retailers over $100 billion annually; abusive returns surged 64% between January 2024 and May 2025 (Ringly.io citing Signifyd). 85% of retailers surveyed have deployed AI to combat returns fraud (NRF, 2025-10-15). See Returns Fraud.

Gaps and data quality notes

  • IMRG UK data gated behind membership; public figures are ~2019–2020. Current granular UK category data unavailable without IMRG subscription.
  • European country-level breakdown: no data for France, Netherlands, or Nordics separately; EU aggregate heavily influenced by German figures.
  • Marketplace sub-channel: Amazon-specific vs ASOS/Zalando return rates not found; DTC vs marketplace split is Eightx portfolio data, not a broad survey.
  • Price-point correlation: no data on how return rates scale with order value within fashion.
  • Sendcloud Delivery Compass 2026 full PDF [1] not extracted this run — would provide per-country European return rates across 8 markets. Recommend download and ingest via _inbox/.
  • Reddit: MCP not connected this run — practitioner perspectives unavailable.

Key terms

TermMeaning
Blended return rateReturns as % of all retail channel sales combined (lower than online-only)
Online return rateReturns as % of online-only sales (higher)
BracketingBuying multiple sizes/colours intending to keep only one
"Returnuary"January surge in returns following holiday gifting
Fully loaded return costIncludes shipping, handling, inspection, restock, markdown, and CS time

References

  1. www.sendcloud.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/EN_EDC_2026.pdf
Research agent · 2026-09-24